The Future of Clean Energy Isn't Now

Green Chip's Weekend Edition

Written by Brian Hicks
Posted June 5, 2010

Welcome to the Green Chip Weekend Edition — our insights from the week in everything alternative and cleantech, as well as links to our most-read Green Chip and sister publication articles. 

It may not be popular, and I'm sure the negative comments will fly, but someone's got to ask it...

Is it time to go long BP (NYSE: BP)?

I ask this purely from an investor's standpoint, which I think is something green investors fail to do all too often.

What I mean is this: In our quest to invest in companies that increase sustainability, we sometimes turn a blind eye (even subconsciously) to real-word economic principles.


Premature Electrification

Take electric cars, for example.

There will come a time when hybrids and electric vehicles make a significant dent in automobile market share, and thereby a significant dent in the amount of petroleum used for that cause.

And as much as we wish and hope and will it to be an overnight transition... the economic and political reality is that that can't happen.

Consider this: The starting price for the Nissan Leaf — the first all-electric 4-door vehicle to go on sale in the U.S. — is $25,280.

You can get a Versa for $10k, a Cube for $14k, a Sentra for $16K, or an Altima or Rogue (Nissan's smallest SUV) for $20K.

The price discrepancy between the Leaf and the Versa (the car the Leaf most resembles) is $15,280. At $3.00 per gallon — which we're currently well below — that would buy you 5,093 gallons of gas.

And with the Versa rated at 34 mpg (I'll use 30 mpg to err on the conservative side), that much gas would allow you to drive 152,800 miles.

So you can buy a Leaf for $25,280 (minimum) and still have to pay for electricity to run it.

Or you could buy a Versa for $10,00 and not reach the break-even cost of a Leaf until you've driven for 153,000 miles.

Listen, I love the environment. I love sustainability. I know cleantech is the way of the future, and will make investors a great deal of money.

But I'm not stupid. I'd buy the Versa every time.

And that's why, in spite of the benefits it promised to the industry, in spite of its MIT lineage, and in spite of the much-hyped and tediously-covered IPO, battery-component maker A123 Systems (NASDAQ: AONE) has performed like this since it debuted:

A123 Systems and Ener1

Ener1, Inc. (NASDAQ: HEV), another electric vehicle battery maker, is in a similar position.

One step at a time

Don't get me wrong... Electric vehicles will ultimately be a great investment. But that doesn't mean they're a great investment now — barring drastic cost reductions and a near-term meteoric rise in the price of oil.

Converting the world's car fleet to electric is an end-game, an ideal. As is the complete eradication of fossil fuel use and an abundance of clean water for all.

But those things can't happen overnight. To think otherwise is silly... And to invest otherwise will help you lose your shirt quickly.

It may not be time to invest in electric vehicles yet, but look at the performance of companies making today's cars more efficient:

Auto Efficiency Stocks

Increasing fuel efficiency isn't the penultimate solution that vehicle electrification is, but it's a real-world, real-time solution based on solid economics.

Instead of forcing the deployment of the Leaf, right now it's smarter to make the Versa go farther on a tank of gas.

And the same can be said about many energy-centric market sectors.

The future isn't now

Of course, to some extent, I'm playing devil's advocate here. The purpose for this is to get you think outside your comfort zone.

Would I really go long BP? Probably not — but it's worth a critical look considering that it's already lost $67 billion of its market value and is showing signs of a bottom.

But whether or not to invest in BP isn't the point here...

The point here is we have to look at the green transition through an agnostic lens — not an indoctrinated or idealistic one — and invest with our brains instead of our hearts. We have to acknowledge and accept the stepping stones allowing us to cross the gap.

Following that mantra will help us make more money in the cleantech market by not missing any opportunities.

That means investing in making today's cars more efficient before investing in tomorrow's electric cars.

In means investing in the grid before commissioning the next wind farm.

And, as we've recently covered, it means investing in reducing energy demand before focusing on increasing supply.

Call it like you see it,


P.S. As always, you can catch up the week's top stories from GCS and our sister publications right here...

Edison’s Evil Plan: American Hero’s Invention Intentionally Flawed
Since its birth 130 years ago, Edison’s light bulb has long been a symbol of American innovation… But most people are completely unaware that the light bulb was created inefficiently on purpose. Lighting costs this country $18bil a year due to this very inefficiency – and it’s created the opportunity for you to net you 14-18 times your money before the end of 2010.

13 Green Stocks for the Next 6 Months: A Green Economic Forecast for The Second Half of 2010
Green Chip Editor Jeff Siegel reviews 13 renewable energy stocks to own for the second half of 2010. 

The Coming LED Boom: Changing Tides Stoke Profits in Efficiency Technology
Editor Nick Hodge recalls what he noticed during a recent fishing foray, and how it could make you big bucks in the lighting game.

Steel, Coke, and Iron Ore Prices are Rising: The Commodity Super-Cycle Continues
Wealth Daily Editor Christian DeHaemer points the way to the next commodity super-cycle. 

Lithium Battery Bonanza: The Chinese Inventor Changing the Face of the Batteries – and the Auto Market
China literally has the lithium market locked down... and this Chinese inventor is about to change the face of the auto industry with his innovative lithium battery technology. This new report from GCS reveals the company that increased net profit by 97% in the last quarter alone.

Investing Insights for the 2010 ASCO Meeting: 7 Top Stocks for the World's Biggest Gathering of Cancer Docs
Wealth Daily Editor Steve Christ offers a preview of this week's American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) Meeting in Chicago.

The Option ARM Crisis 2010-2012: Here's Two Ways to Profit
Energy and Capital Editor Ian Cooper takes a look at two ways to profit in the throes of the coming Option ARM resets.

Third Time’s a Charm for this Energy Company: The Outfit on Pace to be the Nuclear Company in the Country
One little-known company is on record pace to becoming the American nuclear franchise. We’ve already been right about this company twice in the past… There’s still limited time for you to join us as we reap the rewards from this energy investment a third time…

Investing in Uncertain Markets: Divided, Leaderless, Lost: Where's the Bull Market Now?
Energy and Capital Editor Christian DeHaemer gives readers advice on finding bull markets, even in uncertain times, and a simple system for knowing when to buy, when to sell, and when to go golfing.