Advantages & Disadvantages of the MDI Air Car

Tata Motor's MDI Air Car North American Debut

By Emily Rutan
Wednesday, November 5th, 2008

The United States debut of the Zero-Pollution MDI Air Car, licensed by Tata Motors in India is still pending. Recently, however, it seems as though a 2010 unveiling seems to be the most realistic projection.

The time extension may have raised a few eyebrows due to the original proclamation of a 2008 release, yet something has to be said for the expectations that lie behind their meticulous effort.

Still, one has to inquire beyond the buzz of this elusive Air Car.

According to NationMaster.com, the advantages of Tata Motors' engineering masterpiece include possibilities that may be worth the wait. Beginning with the basics, its compressed air engine eliminates the need for a transmission, and in comparison to other vehicles, only calls for a flow control.

The chemistry, size, and design determine the depletion of the battery's charge, but nonetheless provide for a very low self-discharge rate.

The energy exchange of the Air Car's functioning air turbine technology is relatively easy to achieve with low tech materials, and produces zero pollutant emissions from the Air Car itself.

Economically speaking, MDI has rooted the inclusive cost of the Air Car in the cost of overall production. The lack of a cooling system, a fuel tank, spark plugs, and silencers reduce the overall cost of vehicle production by around 20%.

When mass produced, the initial cost of production is significantly lower than battery electric vehicles, supported by the Air Car's identity as a long storage device. In comparison, electrically-operated vehicles have a limited number of uses, which ultimately brings along the expectation of a limited lifetime.

And here's the best news yet: compressed air is not subject to fuel tax.

Even though engineers as MDI have worked to solve many of the problems that are associated with high pressure storage and handling, there are lingering issues revolving mainly around thermodynamics.

Simply speaking, the overall efficiency of the Air Car is roughly one third of an equivalent electric car. These issues stem from compressing air, extended refill times, and the limited range that depends on existing tank technology.

One has to regard these advantages and disadvantages with a bit of perspective on hand. Matters of concern are inevitable with innovative technology, and usually will not be resolved until the possibility of extended use has been made available.

Until then, our only option is to wait. 

Until next time,

Emily

 


Media / Interview Requests? Click Here.



Editor's Note: From solar and wind to geothermal and biofuels, Green Chip readers want to know which renewable energy resource will take over where fossil fuels leave off. The answer is...all of the above!

There is no one single solution to today's energy crisis. However, the combination of all viable renewable energy resources, coupled with energy efficiency, conservation and smart grid development will not only lead us to energy independence and a cleaner, more sustainable energy infrastructure — but also to what will soon prove to be the greatest investment opportunity of the 21st Century.







Rate this article:
 
     Current Rating:  
Article RatingArticle RatingArticle RatingArticle RatingArticle Rating (23 votes)

Comment on this Article


Comments:

Comment by rose on 2008-11-06
This is a great review. Thanks for the insight and I look forward to seeing more info.
Comment by Charlie on 2008-11-20
MDI also announced in 2000 that production in France would start in 2000, and in South Africa and Mexico in 2002. The car specifications were very similar to those that continue to be touted for the "soon to be produced" car.

What happened to the previous production attempts? Why is this set of claims any more reliable than past claims that were never met?

I'll believe it when I see it, or at least when MDI lets some auto magazine or alternative energy group take one of their cars for a test spin. So far, the only published tests showed the MDI car as only being able to go 7.22 km before running out of air!!!

The last word from Tata that I've seen was in August 2008, when they said that the MDI aircar technology was "nascent" and not ready for production, and that production in the near future was ruled out.

References: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/988265.stm

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/988265.stm

http://www.cartradeindia.com/car-bike-news/tata-compressed-air-car-to-take-time-110388.html

Note -- the following link is an archived version of a webpage from the previous MDI corporate website. Details the only actual performance test data that I've ever seen released by MDI. 7.22km (less than 5 mile) range!
http://web.archive.org/web/20071011200005/http://www.theaircar.com/tests.html

SHARE / RATE